Player Star Ratings

Ratings are voted on by registered users. Sign up now to rate your favorite players.

1.

C

Yogi Berra

1946 - 1965

2

10.0

2.

3B

Wade Boggs

1982 - 1999

2

10.0

3.

3B

George Brett

1973 - 1993

2

10.0

4.

P

Nolan Ryan

1966 - 1993

2

10.0

5.

1B

Frank Thomas

1990 - Present

2

10.0

6.

OF

Dave Winfield

1973 - 1995

2

10.0

7.

OF

Carl Yastrzemski

1961 - 1983

1

10.0

8.

OF

Ted Williams

1939 - 1960

1

10.0

9.

P

John Smoltz

1988 - Present

1

10.0

10.

1B

Prince Fielder

2005 - Present

1

10.0

11.

OF

Tony Gwynn

1982 - 2001

1

10.0

12.

OF

Rickey Henderson

1979 - 2003

1

10.0

13.

1B

Eddie Murray

1977 - 1997

1

10.0

14.

OF

Hank Aaron

1954 - 1976

1

10.0

15.

OF

Roberto Clemente

1955 - 1972

1

10.0

16.

OF

Andre Dawson

1976 - 1996

1

10.0

17.

P

Tom Glavine

1987 - Present

1

10.0

18.

1B

Don Mattingly

1982 - 1995

3

9.7

19.

OF

Carlos Quentin

2006 - Present

2

9.5

20.

C

Johnny Bench

1967 - 1983

3

9.3

21.

1B

John Kruk

1986 - 1995

3

9.3

22.

2B

Ryne Sandberg

1981 - 1997

4

9.3

23.

OF

Matt Holliday

2004 - Present

3

9.0

24.

3B

Evan Longoria

2008 - Present

3

9.0

25.

1B

Albert Pujols

2001 - Present

2

9.0

26.

OF

Ken Griffey Jr

1989 - Present

2

9.0

27.

1B

Mark Grace

1988 - 2003

1

9.0

28.

1B

Andres Galarraga

1985 - 2004

1

9.0

29.

OF

Fred Lynn

1974 - 1990

1

9.0

30.

OF

Mickey Mantle

1951 - 1968

1

9.0

1